Since 1917, Girl Scouts have been brightening our days with a mouthwatering selection of cookies.
Favorites like the iconic Thin Mint have captured the hearts—and taste buds—of cookie lovers everywhere.
However, as we gear up for the 2025 cookie season, it’s time to say farewell to two flavors that have carved out a special niche in many cookie aficionados’ hearts.
Farewell to Beloved Flavors
First on the farewell list is Girl Scout S’mores, a flavor that perfectly encapsulated the warmth of camping and the joy of gooey treats when it launched in 2017.
Then there’s the charming Toast-Yays, introduced in 2021 and reminiscent of the comforting tastes of French toast.
While neither cookie achieved ultimate stardom, their departure will undoubtedly leave a void for dedicated fans.
Social media has become a canvas for heartfelt farewells, as enthusiasts openly share their sentiments about these beloved cookies.
One user expressed regret over not ordering enough, while another mourned the loss of their new favorite treat.
With a touch of humor, a resourceful fan even shared plans to squirrel away S’mores cookies in their freezer to stretch out the enjoyment as long as possible.
Embracing New Beginnings for Girl Scout Cookies
While the curtain may be closing on these two specific flavors, there’s still time to savor them.
Fans can grab the last of Girl Scout S’mores and Toast-Yays until the season wraps up in April 2025.
It’s natural to feel a twinge of sadness with their departure.
But there’s a silver lining to consider: the retirement of these two flavors opens the door to fresh and exciting cookies just waiting to be discovered.
Who knows what treats await us in 2026? They could very well become your new favorites!
A representative from the Girl Scouts emphasized that the organization routinely reassesses its cookie lineup to introduce innovative flavors and exciting ideas.
The phase-out of Girl Scout S’mores and Toast-Yays is part of that refreshing cycle, paving the way for new cookies that might soon excite our taste buds.
So let’s look forward with optimism, eagerly anticipating the next delicious creation that might just capture our hearts!
Source: Inspiremore